The Buyers Guide To The Best Frozen Yogurt Maker |

The Buyers Guide To The Best Frozen Yogurt Maker

The Buyers Guide to the Best Frozen Yogurt Maker

It’s rare in life to find a food that tastes delicious but is actually good for you, which is why the world rejoiced when frozen yogurt was born. This amazing treat makes you feel like you’re cheating on a diet and eating ice cream, but you’re actually getting loads of health benefits along with the scrumptious and unique taste.

It makes sense then that people would want this frozen treat more than just sometimes, and so the hunt for the best frozen yogurt maker begins. If you’ve always wanted to have a constant supply of frozen yogurt or experiment with making your own flavors, this is a kitchen gadget that you simply can’t live without.

We’ve searched far and wide to come up with the best frozen yogurt maker and others that came close to securing the title. We also show you what features you should look for when choosing this appliance, and how to get the best use out of it once you have it home.

Our Picks For The Best Frozen Yogurt Maker

After the invention of frozen yogurt, it took appliance manufacturers a while to release that this is a food people want to make at home. Since then, there have been a number of frozen yogurt makers emerge on the market, but not all of them have been worthwhile. We’ve done the hard work for you and chosen the best frozen yogurt maker and runner-up products, so you can choose the perfect one.

Winner: Cuisinart Frozen Yogurt and Ice Cream Maker Review

Cuisinart is one of the leading makers of kitchen appliances, and they also manage to do it for an affordable price. Their two in one Frozen Yogurt and Ice Cream Maker not only make nutritious frozen yogurt but also chilled ice cream, so if you ever feel like being a little unhealthy then you can splurge.

What makes this such a good frozen yogurt maker is how quick it gets the job done. In just 20 minutes, you’ll be able to have the frozen dessert of your choice, and in some cases, it’ll be even faster. This will create restaurant quality frozen yogurt and enough to serve plenty of people as well.

With a larger capacity than most that are available at this price, you can create up to 1.5 quarts of frozen yogurt in the Cuisinart machine. That’s enough to serve around six people at once, or you can keep it frozen so you always have a nutritious dessert or snack ready to go. This will prevent you from reaching for any unhealthy things when you’re trying to watch your diet.

Cuisinart ICE-21 1.5 Quart Frozen Yogurt Review

Judging by some of the reviews, the freezing function of this yogurt maker could be a little better. Some people said they had to freeze longer than the instruction manual recommended, but it really depends on the ingredients you’re using. There’s a double insulated freezer bowl which aids the process along, but you may need to adjust the recipe for efficiency.

One great feature that’s not found in all yogurt makers is the large spout and transparent lid. The spout lets you add ingredients as you go without taking the lid off and having a transparent top means you can see how everything is going with the mixing and freezing process.

Cuisinart has included a booklet with the device that gives you instructions on how to use it and the recipes you can try. However, some customers noted that more information would be helpful, as some instructions were too brief. Looking online, there seem to be a lot of recipes and assistance for anyone with the machine, so it’s obviously a popular buy for a reason.

Runner-Up: Gourmia Frozen Dessert Maker

There are plenty of frozen yogurt makers on the market that use the same approach, mixing a bunch of ingredients together and then freezing it in a special insulated bowl. Gourmia uses a different approach to help you make frozen yogurt though, and some might find it a lot easier to use than others.

The key difference that this frozen dessert maker has is there are no other ingredients required, except for the fruit. You simply place frozen fruit in the machine and it will push out fresh and freezing cold frozen yogurt, so it’s one of the healthier options on the market for sure.

When using the Gourmia Frozen Dessert Maker you don’t have to worry about any artificial colors or flavors, and especially no added sugar. It’s the perfect machine for a family as there’s nothing bad in there for kids. The major downside to using just frozen fruit is that you’ll always need some prepared and ready to go, which might be hard to remember.

Gourmia GSI180 Automatic Healthy Review

Although it sounds easy enough, there were some customers who found it took far too much time. You’ll need to freeze the fruit before you put it in and then it’s quite hard to push through, even if the instructional video makes it look easy. Be prepared to make a bit of a mess while you get the hang of this device.

With this one device you can make frozen yogurt, sorbet, and other frozen natural treats, so it’s pretty versatile in that regard. The manufacturer has said that no other ingredients should be added, even if it’s to your fruit before you freeze, so if you ever wanted to put some protein powder or milk in with the fruit, it’s not possible.

When it comes time to clean the machine, you simply remove the parts and give them a wash. You’ll need to carefully dry them before placing them back, which some customers have said can take a bit of work. If you’re happy to put in some extra effort to get all natural frozen yogurt and don’t mind the prep work, the Gourmia Frozen Dessert Maker could be the one for you.

Alternative: Isiler Frozen Fruit Dessert Maker

Isiler is the brand behind another of our top choices in this style of frozen yogurt maker, giving you a way to have an ice cold treat without any unhealthy ingredients. You simply place your pre-frozen fruits into the machine and it will produce you a smooth, creamy, and cold dessert made with any flavors that you choose.

You’ll need a bit of preparation when using this dessert maker so will always have to keep some frozen fruit in your freezer. However, many of the reviews have stated that this device helped to stop them wasting fruit that would otherwise rot and be thrown out, as now they can place it in their freezer and it’s ready to go whenever they want a frozen yogurt or cold snack.

The problem with this design is that you’re pretty limited in what you can make with it because it’s only going to have frozen fruits and vegetables. If you’re someone who likes a bit more flavor or wants the option to add other ingredients, you’d be better off investing in a frozen yogurt or icecream maker that does the mixing and freezing in one bowl.

Frozen Fruit Dessert Maker

All of the parts are detachable so it’s a lot easier to keep clean in that sense, but you’ll need to carefully follow the instructions getting it apart and putting it back together. There is a manual that comes with it, and it also has some suggestions for recipes like pumpkin puree and strawberry gelato, so it’s handy if you’re looking for inspiration.

Like other frozen dessert makers similar to this model, it’s not as easy as you’d think. You’ll need to hold down the device with one hand and insert the fruit with another, and it tends to get messy. It’s a fun machine to use with your kids, but if you’re not willing to put in the extra effort whenever you want a treat, you may want to spend extra to get something a little easier to use.

This is one of the cheaper options on the market, but it’s still quite good in quality. Isiler offers a three-month money back guarantee for those who try it and don’t like it, so it’s good to have this peace of mind if you’re feeling unsure about which frozen yogurt maker to purchase.

Alternative: Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker

If you’re someone who takes their frozen yogurt very seriously and money is no object, you’ll want to invest in the Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker. Retailing for around 10 times the cost of the others on our list, it’s got plenty of fancy features and means minimal work for you, so you can get expert quality frozen yogurt and ice cream without doing much at all.

This machine offers versatility like no others, and not only can you make frozen yogurt with it, but there are 12 different hardness settings to choose from. This means ice cream, gelato, sorbet, and more are all possible with the one device, so you will get your money’s worth if you can afford to purchase the Breville Smart Scoop.

One major let down with this frozen yogurt maker is how little it makes. You’d expect that for this cost, you could make quite a large quantity, but it only produces 1.5 quarts which is the same as the cheaper model we also reviewed.

Breville BCI600XL Smart Scoop Ice Cream Makers

You’ll be able to find a few ideas for recipes in the instruction book but there are plenty of suggestions online as well. You’ll never run out of options for flavor choices, and you can mix it up when you want a break from frozen yogurt, just be prepared to put in some more time and effort learning all of the new desserts.

It offers a self-refrigerating compressor so there’s no need to put any bowls in the freezer to make your desserts, but some users have recommended it. You can also choose from a fully automatic function where the machine takes over, or the manual setting where you get a lot more say about how it mixes and freezes, as well as the consistency.

For the price, you’d expect a lot more from this machine, but that’s not to say the Breville Smart Scoop doesn’t make delicious frozen yogurt and ice cream. However, with a price tag this high and a lack of size, it seems like investing in one of the cheaper options might be a better idea. For those who can afford it though, this will certainly be a treat to add to your kitchen.

What Exactly Is Frozen Yogurt?

The public production of frozen yogurt can be traced back to the 1970s and early 1980s, where stores began popping up selling the treat through a soft serve machine. People wanted something healthier than ice cream that they could snack on, and yogurt was an easy choice.

These days, frozen yogurt has become a standard choice for dessert, and many times people will opt for it over their treasured ice cream. Yogurt itself has been around for thousands of years, and in addition to being tasty, it actually contains millions of live bacteria that are good for gut health and is naturally low in calories and sugar.

Frozen yogurt is exactly the same, just colder. Making frozen yogurt uses many of the same ingredients and sometimes with the addition of milk or other dairy product to help it set and stay creamy. The blend of creamy milk and the goodness and flavor of yogurt, along with the option of making any flavor one chooses, is why this frozen treat has become so popular.

What’s The Difference Between Ice Cream And Frozen Yogurt?

When it comes to the difference between ice cream and frozen yogurt, there are a few key differences. Keep these in mind the next time you’re trying to decide on what dessert or snack to have:

  • ​When looking at the exact same serving size, frozen yogurt has fewer calories than ice cream.
  • ​There are many healthier options for flavors when it comes to yogurt, like fresh fruit.
  • ​The millions of live bacteria found in yogurt are also found in the frozen variety, so it’s great for gut health.
  • Making frozen yogurt is usually faster than ice cream and requires less freezing time.

​​​​How To Make Your Own Frozen Yogurt

Making frozen yogurt can be done many ways, and just one simple search on the internet will show you so many possible recipes. What you’ll need is the best frozen yogurt maker, ingredients like natural yogurt, some milk or cream, and possibly even some eggs if you want it to have more of an ice cream like consistency.

Place the products in your frozen yogurt maker and then set it to mix and freeze for as long as recommended. Many people believe that removing the bowl once down and placing in the freezer for another couple of hours is the key to getting it cold enough, but again it will depend on the products you’re using.

Make Your Own Frozen Yogurts

Once frozen, you can then get creative with how you eat it. Some might like to put it in a waffle cone on its own, and others will eat it plain. The most popular choice is adding toppings of fresh fruit and nuts to the frozen yogurt, and the more of these you can load up on the more filling your snack will be.

Frozen Yogurt Nutrition Facts

Not all frozen yogurt is created equal, so if you’re buying it in the store you have to be careful about checking nutritional guidelines. A standard frozen yogurt serving is half a cup, and not including the fruit or other toppings, there’s about 115 calories within.

There’s around 17gms of sugar and 4gms of fat per serving, but this can change dramatically depending on how it was made. Nutrition wise, it’s definitely healthier than ice cream, but when you’re buying it made from someone else, there’s no way to tell exactly what you’re getting.

Although frozen yogurt is known as a healthy snack, there’s no way to tell what you’re eating when you buy it from a store. Having your own frozen yogurt maker puts you in control of the ingredients so there’s no risk of eating too many calories or having artificial colors of flavors that just aren’t good for you.

What To Look For When Buying Your Machine

Buying any kitchen appliance can be time-consuming, with so many features to choose from and hundreds of brands that saturate the market. Although we’ve shown you our picks for the best frozen yogurt maker, you need to choose the product that meets your requirements when it comes to features. These are some things to keep in mind when buying this appliance:


There are two main styles of frozen yogurt makers: the ice cream machine and the frozen fruit dessert maker. The ice cream machine also makes yogurt, and you add the ingredients to the bowl and it mixes and freezes it for you. A frozen fruit dessert maker only uses fresh frozen fruit that is pushed through a hole and emerges the other side an icy treat.


Think about the volume of frozen yogurt you’d want to make and ensure that the device can meet this. If you feed a larger family you might want more than the standard 1.5-quart maker, but for small families or single users, this will be more than enough.  A 1.5 quart will make around four cups of frozen yogurt, and with a serving size of half this amount needed, there’s usually plenty to go around.


If you think you’ll want more than just frozen yogurt from your machine, spend a little extra to get one with different options for what it can make. The more expensive brands come with settings like gelato, ice cream, frozen yogurt, and more, so you can mix it up whenever you’re bored.


Cleaning And Maintenance

If you’re someone who doesn’t mind spending time cleaning down their machine, this won’t be as important. For those with limited time, you should choose a yogurt maker that has detachable parts which can be easily washed or even placed in a dishwasher.


The warranty period on any appliance should tell you something about its quality. Look for at least 12 months of warranty to ensure that if something goes wrong, you can recoup the money you spent on it.

An Easy Way To Eat Healthy And Deliciously

We’re always trying to find healthier options for eating these days, with so many sugary and unhealthy treats out there. Frozen yogurt has been popular now for over 30 years and with the emergence of yogurt makers for home, it’s only going to get better.

Having a cup of your own frozen yogurt that you made at home means you’re eating something healthy, and that you know all of the ingredients that went into it. Whether you’re trying to lose weight or just want to make smarter choices with your food, this is one appliance that you shouldn’t be without.

Choosing the best frozen yogurt maker for your kitchen is essential because it has to meet all of your requirements. In addition to being high quality and having a good reputation with customers, you need to consider how its methods, cleaning process, and features tie in with what you need in an appliance.

Any of the frozen yogurt makers we’ve found would be a great addition to your home, and would surely help you find your way towards a healthier lifestyle. The best frozen yogurt maker should make tasty treats, but be easy to use and fun to experiment with, so that you continue eating this nutritious dessert for years to come.

Leave a Comment: